Loonie Tradero

Money, set in type. A free guide to the history of currencies, read from Canada.

Units of account5 min readBy the Loonie Tradero editorial team

Pounds Out, Dollars In: Canada's Decimal Switch of 1858

Decimalisation: replacing a currency's units with ones that divide by ten and one hundred, such as dollars and cents.

Today the Canadian dollar seems as permanent as the maple leaf. Yet for most of the nineteenth century, merchants in what is now Ontario and Quebec wrote their accounts in pounds, shillings and pence. The move to dollars and cents was a deliberate policy decision, and it says a lot about how a unit of account really works.

Counting in pounds without British coins

Before 1858, the official unit in the Canadas was the pound, divided into 20 shillings, each of 12 pence. There were 240 pence to the pound. But the pound used in the colony was not the British pound sterling. It was a local money of account, often called Halifax currency, in which foreign coins were given fixed values.

The most important of those coins was the Spanish silver dollar, which circulated throughout the Americas. Under the Halifax rating, a Spanish dollar counted as five shillings, so four dollars made one pound in local currency. American coins, British coins and French coins all circulated too, each with its own legal rating.

Why change at all

Several pressures pushed the colony toward dollars.

  • Trade with the United States. Commerce with the neighbouring republic was growing, especially after the reciprocity treaty of 1854. American prices were quoted in dollars and cents.
  • Familiar coins. People already thought in dollars, because the Spanish and American dollar coins were the ones they actually handled.
  • Simpler arithmetic. Adding columns of figures in base ten is easier than juggling twelve pence to the shilling and twenty shillings to the pound.
  • Local identity. Colonial politicians wanted a currency suited to North American conditions rather than one tied to British habits.

There was also resistance. Officials in London preferred a sterling-based system that would bind the colony more closely to Britain. The colonial government chose a path between the two: a dollar of equal value to the American dollar, with the British gold sovereign still accepted at a fixed rate.

The switch of 1858

The 1858 reform: a law that required the Province of Canada to keep its public accounts in dollars and cents from 1 January 1858.

The change came in stages. A currency act of 1853 defined a dollar and allowed it to be used alongside the pound. A further law then made dollars and cents the official basis for public accounts from the start of 1858. Merchants, banks and households gradually followed, because tax bills, government salaries and official prices were now written in the new units.

The new dollar was tied to gold and set at par with the American dollar. In practice this meant that the two currencies could be swapped one for one, which suited cross-border traders very well.

Before 1858
1 pound = 20 shillings = 240 pence
Halifax rating
1 Spanish dollar = 5 shillings, so 4 dollars = 1 pound in local currency
From 1858
1 dollar = 100 cents, at par with the American dollar
The arithmetic gain
Adding 3 shillings 9 pence to 7 shillings 6 pence takes two carries; adding 75 cents to $1.50 takes one
Concept figure: two ways of dividing a unit of account, before and after the reform.

New coins for a new unit

A new unit needed new coins. In 1858 the Province of Canada issued its first decimal coins, struck in England: a bronze cent and silver pieces of 5, 10 and 20 cents. They carried a portrait of Queen Victoria on one side and the denomination on the other.

The 20-cent piece did not last. It was close in size to the American 25-cent coin, and people confused the two. When new coins were ordered in 1870, a 25-cent coin took its place. The episode is an early example of a design problem that still matters: coins of different values should be easy to tell apart by touch and by sight.

Coins with the new values also had to win acceptance. For a while, older coins rated in the colonial system kept circulating alongside the decimal ones, and shopkeepers converted between them. Habits changed slowly: some people still quoted prices in shillings years after the reform, much as older Canadians later converted metric measures back into feet and pounds.

Paper money also changed. Notes issued by banks and by the government began to show values in dollars rather than in pounds, and the dollar became the language of everyday prices.

After Confederation

The Province of Canada was not the only colony to change. New Brunswick and Nova Scotia moved to decimal currencies around 1860, but their dollars were not identical to the Canadian one. When the provinces united at Confederation in 1867, they brought different money with them.

A uniform currency act of 1871 brought the provinces onto a single Canadian dollar. Provinces that joined later adopted it as they entered. Newfoundland, which kept its own dollar, only switched to the Canadian dollar when it joined Canada in 1949.

The story of 1858 shows that a currency's name and divisions are choices. They reflect where trade flows, which coins people already trust and what kind of political identity a community wants. The pound did not disappear because it failed. It was replaced because the dollar fitted Canadian life better.

Educational content, not advice

This article explains historical events for general education. It is not financial, investment, tax or legal advice and does not recommend any action. See our Disclaimer.