Loonie Tradero

Money, set in type. A free guide to the history of currencies, read from Canada.

Colonial money5 min readBy the Loonie Tradero editorial team

Playing Cards as Cash: The Card Money of New France

Card money: pieces of playing cards, signed by colonial officials, that circulated in New France as promises to pay in coin later.

In the late seventeenth century, New France had a recurring problem. The colony along the St. Lawrence depended on France for soldiers, supplies and silver, and the silver arrived once a year by ship. When the ship was late, or carried less than expected, the colonial government could not pay its troops. Its answer became one of the earliest experiments with paper money in North America.

A colony without coins

Coins were always scarce in New France. Trade with France ran mostly one way: furs went east, while manufactured goods came west and had to be paid for. Whatever coin reached the colony tended to leave again on the next ship to settle those debts. Local merchants kept accounts in livres, sols and deniers, the French units of the time, but they often settled in goods, in credit or in whatever foreign coins they could find.

This is a pattern that repeats across colonial history. When a territory imports more than it exports, and depends on a distant capital for its money supply, metal coins drain away. People then improvise.

The winter of 1685

In 1685 the intendant of New France, Jacques de Meulles, faced exactly this situation. The funds to pay the soldiers had not arrived, and the next ship would not come until the ice cleared. Paper was in short supply too. Playing cards, however, were available and printed on stiff, durable card.

De Meulles had cards cut into pieces, wrote a value on each, and signed them. He declared that they would be accepted as payment and later exchanged for coin when the money from France arrived. The soldiers could spend them with merchants, and the merchants could return them to the treasury. When the funds came, the cards were redeemed as promised.

How card money worked

A redeemable promise: paper that is worth something because an issuer has promised to exchange it for something else later.

The first issue succeeded, so the experiment was repeated in later years whenever money ran short. The basic features stayed similar:

  • Each card carried a written value and the signatures of colonial officials, which made it harder to forge.
  • Cards were accepted for payments to and from the colonial treasury.
  • At set times, holders could exchange them for bills drawn on the treasury in France.

For a time this arrangement was convenient. Cards were light, easy to count and did not leave the colony the way silver did. An old principle of money also showed up: when good coins and less trusted paper circulate side by side, people tend to keep the coins and spend the paper. Silver that did arrive was often hoarded or shipped back to France, while the cards stayed in circulation.

When the promises multiplied

The weakness of card money was the same as its strength. It was easy to make more. During the long wars of the early eighteenth century, colonial expenses rose and the government in France was short of funds. More cards were issued than could be redeemed on time, and redemption was delayed.

As doubts grew, cards were accepted only at a discount. In 1714 the French government decided to redeem the outstanding cards at half of their face value, and over the next few years the old card money was withdrawn. People who had accepted the cards in good faith absorbed the loss.

The story did not end there. Trade still needed a medium of exchange, and colonists asked for card money to return. A new issue began in 1729, this time with a ceiling on the total amount. Later the colony also used other paper, such as treasury notes known as ordonnances. During the Seven Years' War those issues grew enormously. After the British conquest, France suspended payment on much of its colonial paper, and holders eventually recovered only part of what they were owed.

  1. ShortageCoin from France is late or too small.
  2. PromiseOfficials sign cards and promise coin later.
  3. CirculationCards pass from soldiers to merchants to the treasury.
  4. OverissueMore cards are issued than can be redeemed.
  5. DiscountTrust falls and cards trade below face value.
Concept figure: the life cycle of a paper promise, as seen in New France. Each stage depends on trust in the issuer.

What card money teaches

Card money is often presented as a curiosity, but it illustrates ideas that apply to every paper currency since.

  • Money is a social agreement. A piece of card has almost no value as material. It worked because people expected others to accept it.
  • Credibility is the scarce resource. The issuer's ability and willingness to honour its promise decided what the cards were worth.
  • Limits matter. The second series of card money came with a cap on the total amount for good reason. Without limits, the temptation to issue more is hard to resist.

Historians still debate how much card money helped or harmed the colonial economy. It let trade continue through years when coins were missing, and it also left many holders with losses. Both sides of that record are worth keeping in mind.

New France was not unique. Other colonies in North America issued paper money in the same period, with similar successes and similar problems. What makes the Canadian episode memorable is the object itself: an ordinary deck of cards, turned into a currency by a signature and a promise.

Educational content, not advice

This article explains historical events for general education. It is not financial, investment, tax or legal advice and does not recommend any action. See our Disclaimer.